Hoosier History Live banner

A live weekly radio adventure through Indiana history with host Nelson Price. Airs live on Saturdays from noon to 1 pm ET at WICR 88.7 fm in Indianapolis.

You can listen to WICR anywhere on your mobile device or at home on your smart speaker. Go to www.wicronline.org to listen live. You can also ask your smart speaker to "play WICR" OR "play 88.7 the Diamond".

Listen to the show:

February 11, 2023

Myths and tidbits about high school basketball history

Multi-class basketball that began in the late 1990s killed attendance at games, particularly the tournaments. Girls basketball teams didn't exist at Indiana high schools before the early 1970s. And the first basketball game on Hoosier soil was played in 1894 at a YMCA in Crawfordsville.

All of those are misconceptions, a basketball historian says. So, Hoosier History Live will explore prevailing assumptions about Hoosier high school hoops as well as share tidbits about the history of the sport that has long been part of the state's cultural identity. This will include a look at unusual sites that once served as gyms such as a Studebaker factory in South Bend as well as racial obstacles that confronted a team from Michigan City, Ind., in the 1950s.

Nelson's guest will be Matt Werner, a basketball historian and author based in LaPorte County who is known for his extensive research into the sport's storied past in Indiana. In an in-depth analysis published last March in Nuvo that used data supplied by the Indiana High School Athletic Association (IHSAA), Matt challenged the assumption that the elimination in 1997 of the single-class tournament system in Indiana (immortalized in the movie Hoosiers based on the upset victory in 1954 of tiny Milan High School) killed attendance. Instead, as Matt documented, attendance at tournament games, including sectional, regional and semi-state playoffs, had been in a 25-year slump beginning in 1962, the peak year for tournament attendance. Multi-class basketball, in which Indiana high schools compete against teams of similar size, actually slowed the rate of decline, Matt has concluded.

In addition to delving into whether multi-class basketball unfairly has become a scapegoat for declining attendance. Matt Werner will share insights about the history of girls basketball, which was played at high schools decades before the Title IX (9) Education Amendment in 1972 that called for equalization in sports for boys and girls. Shortridge High School in Indianapolis had a girls basketball team as early as 1898. Girls teams competed into the 1930s even at small high schools such as Union Township High School in LaPorte County, Matt notes.

By the mid-1940s, though, almost all Indiana high schools had dropped girls basketball (and other sports for girls); the public soon forgot they ever had been offered. It wasn't until after Title IX that girls teams were restored, with 1984 becoming the first year that the IHSAA offered an equal number of sports for boys and girls, Matt notes. "In 1972, the IHSAA offered zero sports for girls and 10 sports for boys," he wrote in his analysis of tournament attendance.

Matt is a writer for a documentary about Indiana high school basketball's history that's being produced by WNIT-TV, the PBS affiliate in South Bend; the documentary is expected to be broadcast by PBS stations across Indiana in 2025. He was a guest on Hoosier History Live in 2020 for a show with historian Chandler Lighty that explored the earliest years in Indiana of basketball, which was invented in Massachusetts by Dr. James Naismith, a physical education coordinator at a YMCA.

As on that show, we will explore the long-held claim that the first basketball game in the Hoosier state (where the sport took off like wildfire) was played on March 16, 1894 in Crawfordsville, which touts itself as the "cradle of Indiana basketball". Instead, as Matt will discuss, vintage newspapers from the 1890s describe earlier basketball games in Evansville and Indianapolis; some of the historic newspapers were not easily accessible until recent years when digitization made searching their archives much quicker. Our guest Matt Werner wrote about the myths regarding the earliest games in an article titled "Indiana Basketball Roots Aren't Where You Thought They Were".

Matt is the author of several books, including two planned for publication this year: The Patch Players, about the first Black high school basketball players in Michigan City, and Dispatches from a Northern Hoosier, a collection of his articles and essays. He works on his family's Hoosier Homestead Centennial farm (it has been in his family for more than 100 years) near Union Mills, Ind.

Indiana is home to most of the largest high school gyms in the country. New Castle High School touts its fieldhouse as the largest gym, although the seating capacity eventually became the source of a debate. Hoosier History Live explored the issue in 2020 when Nelson was joined by Chris May, former director of the Indiana High School Basketball Hall of Fame, which also is located in New Castle. Matt Werner plans to comment on the "largest gym" issue during this show.

In addition, he will share insights about what he calls "peculiar" gyms: unusual settings for high school basketball games. Matt has written about the fourth floor of a Studebaker auto factory in South Bend that functioned as the unlikely venue for a game between South Bend Washington High School and Michigan City Elston High School in 1937.

The first state basketball tournament for boys teams was in 1911 and won by Crawfordsville High School.. The most famous game in tournament history is unquestionably the 1954 state championship in which Milan High School upset significantly larger Muncie Central High School. Thanks to a buzzer-beating shot by Milan's star player Bobby Plump, Milan won the game. Bobby Plump was Nelson's guest in March 2014 on the 60th anniversary of the "Milan Miracle", which symbolized the thrilling possibilities of the single-class tournament. The final year of single-class basketball was 1997.

By then, as Matt Werner describes in his article about misconceptions surrounding the multi-class tournament, the number of Indiana high schools (and boys basketball teams) had declined sharply as a result of school consolidation. The number of high school teams participating in the tournament dropped from a peak of 710 teams in 1959 to 382 by 1997. Matt also documents how some Hoosiers had been advocating a multi-class tournament as far back as the 1940s and '50s.

Also during the 1950s, all-Black teams from Indiana high schools began to capture the public's attention, as did African American players on primarily white teams. During our show, Matt will describe the challenges confronted by players in the 1950s from a neighborhood known as "The Patch" in Michigan City. Matt has interviewed players who grew up in The Patch (which was torn down during the 1960s); he has written about how they could not eat at local restaurants or, in other cases, only would be served at the back door with carry-out orders. According to Matt's article, in 1953 the first Black player to lead Elston High School in scoring helped make the love for basketball among Michigan City's residents reach a "fever pitch".

Donate button.

Your contributions help keep Hoosier History Live on the air, on the web and in your inbox!

Roadtrip: Trails Grove African American Cemetery in Henry County

Guest Roadtripper Ricky Cottman of New Castle, Henry County, Indiana is the 4th great grandson of Abram and Ann Marie Cottman. His great grandparents were freed slaves from Fairmont, Virginia, who were brought to Springport in Henry County, Indiana, in 1831. Ricky has written the book "In Colored Circles: The Black American History of Henry County" after developing a passion for learning about his own family history. He can also tell you about his mother's side of the family, who he describes as "free people of color" from Ohio, and were a mixture of Native American, white, and black.

Ricky tells us that "Henry County has a rich history of early African American settlement, including settlements established by escaping slaves who moved north. The most compelling story is that of the William Trail family, who settled in Greensboro Township in 1832. William Trail was a runaway slave from South Carolina who escaped on horseback in 1814 and settled near Connersville, Indiana. He was very bold and a hard worker who cleared land for a living. He was tracked down in 1822 by John Cleveland of Georgia to retrieve and return him to his master in South Carolina. Cleveland bargained with Trail and a man named Cunningham, who paid him $300 for his freedom to pay Blakely.

Cleveland, instead of giving the money to Blakely, bought a horse and had Trail jailed in Connersville. A trial ensued and William Trail was allowed to testify in court. Through this unusual early court case, William Trail became a free man. He married Sarah McCown in 1825 and purchased many acres in Greensboro Township near the present town of Shirley".

The cemetery is one of the most significant African American sites in Henry County. Although the land is no longer in the Trail family, it is on farmland that can be reached with permission during non-planting seasons.


You may have noticed that we are not automatically editing and posting our weekly show podcasts

"Alas, for now, this is a belt tightening measure" says executive producer Molly Head. "As with many small media organizations, we must continue to cut costs.

We continue to collect and keep safe all our current show audio, however. I think Hoosier History Live is an amazing media product, and no one does Indiana history coverage and localism as we do. We have successfully created showbiz out of history.

If you would like to contribute to Hoosier History Live, you can do so at the yellow button on our website www.hoosierhistorylive.org”  

"Connoisseur of all things Hoosier" weighs in on Dillinger 

Thanks to the Indianapolis Business Journal for checking in with intrepid host Nelson Price about the fabled Hoosier gangster John Dillinger. Nelson has always contended that "Dillinger robbed this place" or "Dillinger held up this bank" is a common Indiana misconception.

The show must go on!

The Hoosier History Live mediamakers at Capitol Ave. Starbucks, Indianapolis, February 1. Molly Head, executive producer, Corene Nickel, web designer, Nelson Price, host and historian.


Logo propylaeum

Logo Lucas oil

We'd like to thank the following recent individual contributors who make this show possible. For a full list of contributors over the years, visit  Support the Show on our website.

  • Mike Freeland and Sharon Butsch Freeland 
  • Dr. William McNiece
  • Robin Winston
  • Ann Frick
  • James Fadely
  • In memory of William (Bill) Mihay by Bob Wakefield
  • Florence and John Stanton
  • Aleta Hodge
  • Peggy Hollingsworth
  • Lorraine Phillips Vavul
  • Margaret Smith
  • Jane Hodge
  • Jeff Price

Molly Head, executive producer (317) 506-7164 
Nelson Price, host and historian
Corene Nickel, web designer and tech manager

Richard Sullivan and Ryan DeRome, tech consultants
Cheryl Lamb, administrative manager
Pam Fraizer, graphic designer


Please tell our sponsors that you appreciate their support!

Facebook logo links to the Hoosier History Live! page.Twitter logo for Hoosier History Live.Acknowledgments to WICR-FM, Fraizer Designs, The Indiana Album, Monomedia, Indiana Historical Bureau, Indiana Landmarks, Henri Pensis, Kielynn Tally, Genesis Brown, Leticia Vasselli, Heather McIntyre, and many other individuals and organizations. We are independently produced and are self-supporting through organizational sponsorship and through individual contribution at the yellow button on our newsletter or website. For organizational sponsorship, which includes logos, links, and voiced credits in the show, contact Molly Head at (317) 506-7164 or email her at molly@hoosierhistorylive.org

Donate button.

Your contributions help keep Hoosier History Live on the air, on the web and in your inbox!

© 2023 Hoosier History Live. All rights reserved.

Share this email
Manage your preferences | Opt out using TrueRemove®
Got this as a forward? Sign up to receive our future emails.
View this email online.
This email was sent to [% member:email %].
Continue receiving our emails, add us to your address book.